- Executive Coaching Yields Return On Investment Of
Almost Six Times Its Cost, Says Study…
"...believed to be the first major study to quantify the business impact of
executive coaching. The study included 100 executives, mostly from Fortune 1000
companies, who received coaching...Half of the executives in the study held
positions of vice president or higher (including division president, general
manager, chief executive officer, chief financial officer, chief information
officer, partner, principal, and practice leader). Almost six out of 10 (57%)
executives who received coaching were ages 40 to 49, and one-third earned
$200,000 or more per year.
The coaching programs that executives participated in were a mix of both
change-oriented coaching -- which is aimed at changing certain behaviors or
skills -- and growth-oriented coaching -- which is aimed at sharpening
performance. The coaching programs typically lasted from six months to one
year.
Among the results of the study: The coaching programs delivered an average
return on investment of 5.7 times the initial investment in a typical executive
coaching assignment -- or a return of more than $100,000 -- according to
executives who estimated the monetary value of the results achieved through
coaching.
Among the benefits to companies that provided coaching to executives were
improvements in:
- Productivity (reported by 53% of executives) Quality (48%) Organizational
strength (48%) Customer service (39%) Reducing customer complaints (34%)
Retaining executives who received coaching (32%) Cost reductions (23%)
Bottom-line profitability (22%)
Among the benefits to executives who received coaching were improved:
- Working relationships with direct reports (reported by 77% of executives)
Working relationships with immediate supervisors (71%) Teamwork (67%) Working
relationships with peers (63%) Job satisfaction (61%) Conflict reduction (52%)
Organizational commitment (44%) Working relationships with clients (37%)..." -
(BUSINESS WIRE)--Jan. 4, 2001
-
"As a $100 million business second only to the IT
industry in its US growth rate, coaching is the latest must-have
lifestyle and business accessory - the solution to both workplace
under-achievement and premature stress burnout." Vive ,2000
-
"Call it professional coaching, executive coaching, life coaching, or
corporate coaching. Whatever the name, this new phenomenon is one of the hottest services in corporate America today.
Some data show that the quality of the relationship between boss and subordinate
is a major predictor of intentions to remain. Coaching--which can help managers
talk with subordinates about their developmental needs--absolutely affects that
relationship positively. And there's a big potential payoff."- says David A.
Thomas, Fitzhugh professor of business administration at Harvard Business
School. THE BUSINESS JOURNAL April , 2000
-
"Between 25 percent and 40 percent of Fortune 500
companies use executive coaches" - according to a recent survey by
The Hay Group, an international human resources consultancy
-
"The leaders of organizations such as Alcoa, American Red Cross, AT&T,
Ford, Northwestern Mutual Life, 3M, UPS, American Standard, the federal
governments of the United States and Canada are convinced that coaching
works to develop people and increase productivity." - Consulting to
Management (Sept.2001)
-
"Coaching management is a hot trend at a growing number of FORTUNE 500
companies, from IBM and Dow Chemical to Marriott International and Glaxo
Wellcome. Corporate coaches are in such demand that they can charge from
$600 to $2,000 a month for three or four 30- to 60-minute conversations. Some
charge as much as $400 an hour. So a lot of them are earning far more than
psychologists or psychiatrists.
Coaches are everywhere these days. Companies hire them to shore up executives
or, in some cases, to ship them out. Division heads hire them as change agents.
Workers at all levels of the corporate ladder, fed up with a lack of advice from
inside the company, are taking matters into their own hands and enlisting
coaches for guidance on how to improve their performance, boost their profits,
and make better decisions about everything from personnel to strategy. "-
TIME Business News
-
"Coaching is needed today more than ever as a critical tool for
organizational change... Change is essential for an organization to grow and
adapt to today's rapidly shifting marketplace...In changing from old
hierarchical models to relational models for leading and influencing, businesses
are creating coaching cultures that encourage organizational learning. Coaching
has emerged as the best way to help individuals learn to think and work together
more effectively."- Georgetown University, Center for Professional
Development. 2002
-
At Harvard Business School, Linda Hill, professor of business
administration, says - she's inundated with requests to coach. "Coaching
is becoming something of a heavy industry. It's amazing," - says Warren
Bennis, professor of business administration at the University of Southern
California's business school.
-
"If ever stressed-out corporate America could use a little couch-time,
it's now. Trust in big companies is at an all-time low. Baby-boomers have
been burned; Gen Xers aren't expecting the Corporation to take care of them.
Under the circumstances, employees are much likelier to go outside and get
independent advice to help them be better managers" - says Karen Cates,
assistant professor of organizational behavior at Northwestern's Kellogg
Graduate School of Management.
-
"What's really driving the boom in coaching, is this, as we move from
30 miles an hour to 70 to 120 to 180...as we go from driving straight down the
road to making right turns and left turns to abandoning cars and getting on
motorcycles...the whole game changes, and a lot of people are trying to keep up,
learn how, not fall off." - says John Kotter, professor of leadership at the
Harvard Business School.
-
The demand for Executive Coaches has skyrocketed over the past 5
years... today’s executive coach (EC) is intended to help leaders and
potential leaders across the rocky, wild, and challenging road of organizational
growth in today’s dynamic and unstable work environment....As with most emerging
professions, the rules and guidelines for how to make executive coaching work
have been scanty at best. This gap has been felt by executives seeking help,
their organizations, and the scores of people putting up shingles as EC’s. At
the same time, a cadre of other types of coaches is trying to catch the
coattails of the popularity of executive coaching." - The Society for
Industrial and Organizational Psychology - American Psychological
Association
-
Booz, Allen & Hamilton's Ed Cohen, Director for Professional Excellence
says; "We hire outside certified coaches to help our executives fill in minor
gaps that may not have shown up earlier in the person's career because those
skills may not have been the ones that were needed to help them rise to their
present level." - The Edge, 2002
-
"Coaching is the only cost-effective way to reinforce new behaviors and
skills until a learner is through the dangerous results dip. Once through
the dip, when the new skills bring results, they will become self-reinforcing."
Training and Development Journal.
-
"We've done lots of research over the past three years, and we've found that
leaders who have the best coaching skills have better business results."
V.P. of Global Executive & Organizational Development at IBM.
-
"Corporations believe that coaching helps keep employees and that the
dollar investment in it is far less than the cost of replacing an employee."
Fitzhugh professor of Business Administration, Harvard Business School —above
two quotes from TIME Magazine (Sept 25, 2000) article about Executive
Coaching
-
Workforce Trends
(COACHING SURVEY) According to the survey, senior-level managers need
to pay more attention to, and focus more closely on, their people skills as
companies decrease managerial levels and increase the number of employees each
manager manages. The survey found the senior-level executives' top five
management behavioral problems — or, problems with how they manage people —
are:
-
Poor communications skills — both written and verbal, which 41% of
survey respondents selected as the main top-level management problem in their
organizations
-
Failure to develop subordinates — chosen by 32% of human resource
managers
-
Rigid and inflexible management behavior — 29%
-
Indecisive and/or nonassertive management behavior — 20%
-
Not being a team player — 18%
The top five employee relations problems that senior-level executives
most need to correct in order to work more effectively with others are:
-
Poor interpersonal skills, selected by 48% of survey respondents as
the No. 1 top-level employee relations problem in their organizations
-
Disorganization — 31%
-
Demeaning attitude — 22%
-
Unpredictability – 21%
-
Arrogance — 21%
The survey concludes that progressive organizations are increasingly
utilizing executive coaches for their managers and enrolling them in
interpersonal skills-building courses. These methods have enhanced both the
executive performance and team effectiveness of the organizations. -
Manchester Executive Coaching Survey
-
"With the aggressive marketing of executive coaching by consultants, it is
becoming increasingly difficult to obtain an objective view about what it is."
This report has found "the reasons for the phenomenal growth in the use of
executive coaching by employing organizations seem to include: a) the
knock-on effects of the downsizing of the 1990s, resulting in ‘lonely’ and
isolated senior managers who welcome support and challenge from someone external
to their immediate work environment. b) The increasing demand by organizations
for senior managers with key ‘soft skills’. Many business schools and in-company
standard development programs have failed to embed the kinds of feedback-based
approaches necessary for self-insight and the acquisition of soft skills, for
managers when they were more junior. c) Some senior managers consider they have
‘made it’ and worry that being seen to undergo development may be perceived by
others as admitting they have a weakness. The nature of the executive coaching
relationship is private and avoids that public gaze. d) Attendance on whole-day
courses or regular learning sets can seem an imposition into an already busy
schedule. Sessions with executive coaches can be fitted around other diary
commitments." -IES Research (a group of 30 of the UK’s leading employers)
Report 379, April 2001.
-
"The Xerox Corporation carried out several studies, one of which
showed that in the absence of follow-up coaching 87% of the skills change
brought about by the program was lost. That’s 87 cents in the skills dollar.
However good your skills training in the classroom, unless it’s followed up on
the job, most of its effectiveness is lost without follow-up coaching. For
example: Most sales people try out the new skills for a few calls, find that
they feel awkward and the new method isn’t bringing instant results, so they go
back to their old ways.
-
Coaching Case study: Qualitative survey across all key sectors with
Senior HR and Operational Line Managers. "One person who had received coaching
for a non-fixed period felt that the impact of this relationship was that she
was able to add more than £15 million to the organisation through the
interventions which she made possible.- British Psychological Society.
Selection and Development Review. Vol 17, 1 February 2001
-
According to a study by F. Masterpasqua, PhD, (a clinical psychology
professor at Widener University), business leaders increasingly realize that
helping employees balance their work/family demands is part of getting a
commercial competitive edge. "Believe me, I know Fortune 500 companies
aren't driven by altruism," said Masterpasqua. "They're after that competitive
edge." Masterpasqua, recently surveyed 56 executives--half of them chief
executive officers, the other half human resources directors--and found that
most considered work/family balance a major "issue for their company." Many also
felt the pressure personally affected their productivity and quality of work.
Corporate executives that he coaches have a common struggle: to manage work and
family responsibilities and not let the stress of one arena spill into the
other.
-
Case study: Deloitte Consulting UK: Summary Findings -"Don't make
coaching a separate initiative - embody it in the culture. Senior management
'walking the talk' and being role models is important. Do it wholeheartedly and
only use the best quality external support."
-
"A study featured in Public Personnel Management Journal reports that
managers (31) that underwent a managerial training program showed an increased
productivity of 22.4%. However, a second group was provided coaching
following the training process and their productivity increased by 88%.
Research does demonstrate that one-on-one executive coaching is of value." -
by F. Turner, Ph.D. CEO Refresher 2001.
-
Some Executive Coaching Facts and Figures ...in the US
-
Executive/Business Coaches charge by the hour, by the month or by the
project. Expect to pay the equivalent of a management consultant's fee. Rates
run $150 to $375 per hour.
-
Most people who hire executive coaches are professional people whose average
age is 41 and who have college or advanced degrees.
-
According to the ICF, clients report the following outcomes as a result of
working with a coach:
- Self-awareness 67.6%
- Setting better goals 62.4%
- More balanced life 60.5%
- Lower stress levels 57.1%
The ICF currently estimates that 15,000 people call themselves business
coaches in the United States.
-
Accenture's Alastair Robertson, manager of worldwide leadership
development practice in Boston, says employers are shocked at how high their ROI
numbers are for coaching. He recalls a large employer in the hospitality
industry saved between $30 million and $60 million by coaching its top 200
executives.
-
IBM have hired 30 organizational psychologists to coach 300 top
managers. It credits them with "creating a climate where everyone in the
organization feels empowered and capable and committed," says Tanya Clemons, the
IBM vice president overseeing executive development. "We can already see the
results."
-
Motorola say they expect to spend "in the low millions" this year on
executive coaching for their best middle managers.
-
Unilever, the Anglo-Dutch conglomerate, has thirty coaches working in
Europe, Asia, Latin America and Africa with 250 top managers.
-
Eastman Kodak's Charles Barrentine states "It boils down to caring."
He oversees 4,000 employees and finds coaching "invaluable. It points out things
people would not notice themselves and plays a big role in shaping
behavior."
-
Abbott Laboratories Tony Latham, divisional V.P. for executive
sourcing and development for World Wide sees executive coaching as a way to help
valued employees evolve in a swiftly changing business environment and is
starting up an in-house coaching program. "It's basic human nature," he
says.
-
"People, rather than companies, do hire their own coaches -- some of whom
charge as little as $50 an hour for phone or e-mail consultations. Companies
pay up to $100,000 for yearlong engagements with CEOs, or $5,000 to $15,000
for a three-month engagement with senior managers." -May 28, 2001. The
Associated Press
-
"Fees range dramatically. Business coaches can range from $150 to
$1000 per hour, with $300 to $500 per hour being the more common range. Personal
coaches rates are typically much less, with $75 to $100 per hour being usual."
-HR.com
-
"..business coaching, a trend that's exploding among small businesses and
entrepreneurs nationwide. It's estimated that up to 20% of American small
businesses are using them, up from 4% just four years ago."- Chicago
Business
-
"..the number of job coaches (career coaches) has grown from 5,300 nationwide
in 1998 to approximately 10,000 in 2001. Job coaching has become a $250
million industry and shows no sign of slowing. And it is not just a U.S.
phenomenon. It has been reported that there are currently over 15,000 job
coaches active in China alone, with other countries also using coaches...For
career changers in uncertain economic times, a job coach is someone who can help
them advance in their careers and achieve their goals, can make the difference
between a satisfying career path and ongoing unemployment." - (BUSINESS WIRE)
-July 30, 2001